Indo-Nordic Developmental Exchanges

Denmark’s PM gave a tour of her residence to PM Modi and accompanied him to the Indian Diaspora event. The visit of PM Narendra Modi to Denmark puts the spotlight back on the Nordic countries, which are often ranked as the happiest countries topping the Human Development Indices (HDI). Nordic countries include Sweden, Finland, Denmark, Norway and Iceland. In the recent happiness race, Finland stood at the top for the fifth year in a row, closely followed by Denmark. This makes it interesting to know as to what pedestals them as the happiest countries globally and in what way both sides (India & Nordic) can expand their collaboration and mutually benefit from that.

PM Modi in his departure statement ahead of this Europe visit had said, “Nordic countries are important partners for India in sustainability, renewable energy, digitisation and innovation. The visit will help in expanding our multifaceted cooperation with the Nordic region.” The first India-Nordic Summit had taken place in 2018, which provided a perfect platform to come together and realise the full potential of the partnership. Now, the second India-Nordic Summit with Prime Ministers of Denmark, Iceland, Finland, Sweden and Norway acquires greater importance, where India discusses a whole host of cooperation. The agenda of the summit includes subjects like post-pandemic economic recovery, climate change, sustainability, digitization, technology, renewable energy, global security scenario and India-Nordic cooperation in the Arctic region.

In the broader picture, mutual economic interests have been the primary driver of the relations between India and Nordic countries where both have put ‘ease of doing business’ at the core of developmental strategy. In fact, in the last few years India has opened up more ground for investment within the nation and abroad. Of the five Nordic countries, four are among the top 20 trading partners of India in Europe – Sweden at 9th, Finland 10th, Denmark 12th and Norway at 14th rank.

Many of the Nordic companies have invested in India in various sectors. Sweden & Finland have invested substantially in India. Similarly, 200 Danish companies and around 100 Norwegian companies are engaged in India either through joint ventures or through wholly owned subsidiaries. Over the last few decades, Indian investment in Nordic countries has also increased with over 70 big Indian companies having their presence in Nordic region. However, there is still tremendous scope for expanding economic ties. Both sides also share democratic values and support for the multilateral rules-based world order. India presents an ideal opportunity for these countries because of its large market and the fastest growing economy.

Rejuvenating India EU ties amidst turmoil

From political and economic tensions in Sri Lanka to the Ukraine-Russia conflict, the world’s political landscape seems grim and rickety right now. As PM Narendra Modi begins his three-day visit to Europe with a spirit high on multilateralism, renewed relations with the European Continent may allow India to explore plurilateral arrangements to generate more global opportunities and solutions in trade, connectivity and new technologies.

The visit of PM Modi to Europe also could not have been timed better from the view point of the old economies of Europe; and India, an emerging power in a multipolar world, spearheading global development. The EU has been able to stabilise and integrate Europe to a good extent. The continent, a group of old economies with same socioeconomic fabric, however has a large part of population that suffers with depressive disorders with higher prevalences in women, the middle-aged, less privileged groups, and those experiencing social adversity. Prevalence rates are much higher in more economically developed nations as there’s nothing much to build and innovate. India which has become severely vocal to promote Yoga, Ayurveda, and Spiritualism as key to rejuvenation of body and mind, promises unprecedented change to the world. With powerful initiatives like Make In India, endorsement of Indian Tourism and exploration of niche tourism, introduction of PLI scheme in various sectors, endorsement of UPI in foreign countries, efforts to increase FDI, new FTA & Trade strategies, etc. India has been trying to convey to the world its readiness for cultural exchange, better economic partnership, and its newfound openness to engage with communities across the globe for mutual development. As diversities change rapidly across the world, a new perspective is needed to manage religious and cultural differences with innovation and soft power diplomacy.

Similarly, India also seems to have realised that a traditional approach to Europe is not appropriate amid the changing World order. Approaching the European continent through its relations with individual countries instead of EU may not strengthen the relations as desired. India has recognised that it the European collective which is its largest trade, key technological and investment partner and can be increasingly important ally to count upon in times of crisis related to Indian Ocean and the wider Middle East. Hence, an FTA with EU, with aggressive efforts being put from both sides to reach to an agreement, would result in super strengthened ties.

Acknowledging and taking on to the needs of changing paradigm, both Europe and India have been engaging in rolling out new initiatives and holding discussions around subjects of economic & technological relevance. The EU is on the front foot in designing global rules in field like protection of personal data; setting up human-centric standards for the use of AI, actively acting on its take on taxation in a digital world. EU has given its nod to new standards on industrial subsidies, largely seeking a renewal within WTO and pinning China. Majority of the above mentioned factors naturally fall in line with the vision of New India, with security of high waters, protection of Indo-Pacific region, diplomatic support at International Forums and greater trade and defence engagement being areas of utmost priority and potentials.

Delivery and Language of Courtrooms

One can argue that judicial communication is an area needing urgent reforms, both in terms of timely delivery of justice as well as delivery in common person’s language. PM Modi echoes the mood when he says, “A large population finds it difficult to understand the judicial process and rulings of the court. There is a need to simplify this and make it accessible. We just encourage the use of local languages in courts. This will ensure that the common man has faith in the judiciary and can feel part of the system.” He expressed these at the inauguration of the 11th Joint Conference of Chief Ministers and Chief Justices of High Courts, highlighting yet another need of the hour to make judiciary more inclusive and explicit.

Various regions have demanded from time to time to allow the use of local language in the proceedings before the high courts as provided under Article 348 of the Constitution. The matter has long been a matter of debate too. Certain barriers have prevented local language from being adopted for the proceedings before the high courts. Some of the prominent ones, as highlighted by CJI Ramana, include the fact that sometimes some of the judges are not familiar with the local language & that the Chief Justice are always from outside. However, the government is trying to find solutions to many of such outstanding issues through technology. “I am sure with the innovation in science and technology, the advancement such as Artificial Intelligence, some of the issues associated with the introduction of languages in the high courts may be solved in the near future,” says CJI Ramana.

While lower courts function in local languages and English, the High Courts and Supreme Court use English in their proceedings. The move of adoption of local languages in court would help the common man relate to the judiciary like never before. The Prime Minister also parallelly underlined yet another pressing issue i.e. the need of endorsing medical and technical education in mother-tongue that can help the country have more and more engineers and doctors. “I am glad the Chief Justice of India mentioned having High Courts using local languages. It will take a long time for that, but it will improve access to justice. Why can’t medical and technical education be done in the mother tongue? Some states are already doing it,” PM Modi said while also conveying to and assuring people that the government is even working towards simplifying laws passed in Parliament for the common man to understand them. “Along with the actual legislation, if a simplified version is also passed in Parliament for the common man to understand, then he will not have to go to the court for interpretation of the law. The government is studying this issue,” he said.

The government seems to have been looking towards solution that can improve the judicial system and upgrade the judicial infrastructures. Efforts are being seen to fill up vacancies in courts. Further, use of technology in the judicial system is now an essential part of the Digital India mission. AI, machine learning, natural language processing, digital sharing and record-keeping, etc. are some of the solutions that are already being explored and examined. “To explore the use of AI in judicial domain, the Supreme Court of India has constituted Artificial Intelligence Committee which has mainly identified application of AI technology in Translation of judicial documents; Legal research assistance and Process automation,” Law Minister Kiren Rijiju stated recently in Parliament conveying about implementation of phase two of the eCourts projects of the government. Another stepping stone towards this new-age judicial ecosystem was set with the launch of the AI-driven research portal SUPACE (Supreme Court Portal for Assistance in Courts Efficiency) last year. The portal deals with large chunks of case data through machine-learning

“How do we make our judicial system so capable that it can fulfill the aspirations of India of 2047, … these questions should be our priority today,” said PM Modi invoking a vision for the future of the judiciary and urging the Judges and Chief Ministers to set the vision for the nation in 2047, when India would celebrate 100 years of independence. As the New India begins to dawn and shape up, it is bringing a wave of change in every domain that helps run the country, including the Indian Judiciary. The judiciary system is being made more relevant, tech-ready, transparent and accessible for all. From working on deciding upon as to what all court-related proceedings and matters can be made public to implementation of e-courts project in mission mode, efforts are seen to make Indian Judiciary trusting and impactful for New India.